BookSleuth®
BookSleuth® Tips
GiftSleuth

Is there a special book that you read, or perhaps had read to you, at some point in your life but you can't remember the author and title? Perhaps you know the plot, or a character, or maybe even what the front cover looks like. BookSleuth® is here to help you find that book! Simply post a short description of what you can remember here on our board. Visitors from all over the world will read your post, and one of them is bound to know exactly what you're talking about and post a response. Not missing anything? Why not see if you can help anyone else find their long-lost books?

-

Back To Discussion List

 General -  Please helpnotify me whenever anyone posts in this discussionSubscribe  
 
From: jrs82  3-Nov 12:55 
to: ALL  1 of 12 
 3709.1 
Hi, I'm trying to find a book that I read in junior school about people trying to create a black rose. Its set in a house surrounded by a topiary garden, there are lots of weird characters and I think a murder. Sorry I don't have more go on!
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: beachball  11-Nov 13:58 
to: jrs82 Unread  2 of 12 
 3709.2 in reply to 3709.1 

i think it is called the black delia if spelt right hope this is right

 

 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: pembe  16-Nov 00:18 
to: beachball Unread  3 of 12 
 3709.3 in reply to 3709.2 
The Black Dahlia maybe?

Pembe

 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: Rocambole  16-Nov 14:38 
to: pembe  4 of 12 
 3709.4 in reply to 3709.3 

Somehow I doubt it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Dahlia

It's such a notorious (and vicious) murder case I can't imagine it being used for an unrelated book.


Rocambole
_@'
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: Bedworth  17-Nov 02:04 
to: Rocambole  5 of 12 
 3709.5 in reply to 3709.4 
There's a novel (James Ellroy) and a movie based on the case. Not to mention lots of True Crime stuff. Not impossible that someone could have used the same title, maybe unconsciously. You'd hope an editor would pick up on it, but given the lack of proof-reading in many books, perhaps not.
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: Rocambole  17-Nov 03:15 
to: Bedworth  6 of 12 
 3709.6 in reply to 3709.5 
That's my point, really - it's *so* notorious and *so* nasty that I can't see it as a title getting past editors, legal department, etc etc. I can actually see publishing houses pulping a run if they twigged too late - it'd be like having a childrens' book heroine called Myra Hindley or something.

Rocambole
_@'
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: pembe  17-Nov 08:42 
to: Rocambole  7 of 12 
 3709.7 in reply to 3709.4 
Eurgh. I do see what you mean.

Pembe

 
   Options Reply 
  

Message 8 of 12 was Deleted  

 
From: Bedworth  18-Nov 08:26 
to: Rocambole  9 of 12 
 3709.9 in reply to 3709.6 
I understand what you mean, though I suspect that the murder's only really well known in its own community and to true-crime fans. The original post did sound vaguely familiar, though.
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: winelover  18-Nov 09:46 
to: jrs82 Unread  10 of 12 
 3709.10 in reply to 3709.1 
I wonder if what you're looking for is actually "The Black Tulip" (Alexandre Dumas). That involves a murder, & it used to be quite a popular children's book - years ago there was a TV serialisation as well.
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: Rocambole  19-Nov 00:31 
to: Bedworth  11 of 12 
 3709.11 in reply to 3709.9 

America's such a large market, and I think titles are routinely run past lawyers (not to mention writers' friends and family and everyone at the publishers' and agents' offices, and, these days, Google)... I just don't think it'd get past all that.

Though maybe it did, in a small print run, and the OP's one of only a few who ever read it!


Rocambole
_@'


Edited 19/11/2009 00:32 ET by Rocambole
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: Bedworth  19-Nov 02:28 
to: Rocambole  12 of 12 
 3709.12 in reply to 3709.11 
Always a possibility, with so much vanity publishing and self-publishing around.
 
   Options Reply 
  

Rate My Interest:
   
Adjust text size:
Is this too complicated? Switch to Basic View

Back To Discussion List